AI & Governance
Before an AI Assistant Pilot, Define What It May and May Not Do
Scope an AI assistant pilot with explicit permissions, human review, evaluation cases, and a practical stop condition.
Accumentum® ·
Define the permitted task, allowed data, expected behavior, and human decision owner before testing. Evaluate correctness and authorization separately, then set a stop condition for a consequential failure.
A pilot that saves staff drafting time can still create risk if it exposes confidential data, invents instructions, or shifts work into an unmeasured review queue. AI pilot governance should begin with a narrow approved use, representative evaluation cases, clear human accountability, and a decision about what evidence is required for expansion. A compelling demo is not a deployment authorization.
NIST's AI Risk Management Framework organizes activities into Govern, Map, Measure, and Manage. In practical terms, identify accountable owners, the intended task, the people affected, plausible failures, evaluation measures, and risk treatment. Define the system's input sources, retention, permissions, output destinations, and human review boundary. Reopen the assessment whenever the purpose, users, or data exposure changes.
How to practice
- Set the boundary: Describe the approved task, excluded uses, input classes, affected users, and failure consequences.
- Choose evaluation: Build a fixed set of routine, difficult, ambiguous, and adversarial cases.
- Measure the full workflow: Track quality, correction effort, latency, safety issues, and actual end-to-end time.
- Gate expansion: Name the authority who reviews evidence and can pause or roll back the release.
The workplace scenario
An assistant was approved to draft internal meeting notes. A team proposes using it to summarize customer calls and send results externally. That change introduces customer data, communication accuracy, consent and retention considerations, and reputational consequences. The right response is to reopen scope and evaluation, not to argue that the underlying model has already been tested.
Turn the pilot charter into an acceptance test
Consider an internal assistant that helps staff locate approved travel policies. Limit the first pilot to finding the relevant policy and citing its current approved version. A response about a traveler’s personal eligibility or an exception requiring manager approval needs a human owner. Write one evaluation case for a straightforward lookup, one for an ambiguous question, one for a superseded policy, and one where the requester lacks access to the source. Give each case an expected outcome before the pilot begins.
Now score two different dimensions. Did the assistant give the right information, and was it permitted to use and disclose that information in this context? A factually accurate answer drawn from a restricted source fails the second test. Conversely, referring a genuinely ambiguous case to the policy owner can be the correct outcome. Keep the questions, source versions, reviewer decisions, and unresolved disagreements together so that a later team can repeat the evaluation.
Give the owner a decision they can make
Suppose nine simple lookups pass, but a restricted-source case fails. A single average would make that result look reassuring. Put it in a separate release condition and identify who can suspend the pilot, which capability is affected, and what evidence is needed to restart. The pilot now tests a bounded business service with an accountable owner.
A common mistake
A single "accuracy" number may mask important failure modes. Examine errors by scenario and affected group, and record which risks are not measured. Do not claim that human review solves every risk without proving reviewers can detect the errors at the intended scale.
Try it yourself
Write a one-page pilot charter covering intended use, prohibited use, data classification, five test cases, acceptance criteria, owner, monitoring, and emergency stop. Add one sentence stating what would force reapproval.
When should an AI pilot be expanded?
Only after a defined owner reviews representative results, unresolved risks, operating controls, and the actual business benefit against the agreed threshold.
Put it into practice
Use PathHire's AI Governance Analyst or AI Program Manager pathways for bounded-release decisions. Accumentum AI training can strengthen risk and implementation foundations.
Further reading
- NIST AI Risk Management Framework
- NIST: Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework, Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile